Thanks to Jim Arnzen and Matt Payton for providing this information. Here is a list of Trojans who made Associated Press First Team All-Ohio:
1949-50: Bert Barney
1960-61: Mike Haley
1963-64: Larry Hisle
1964-65: Larry Hisle.........also made First Team All-American in 1965 with Lew Alcindor (Kareem Abdul-Jabbar)
1978-79: Craig Tubbs
1981-82: Chris Gentry
1983-84: Kyle Taylor
1986-87: Patrick Tubbs
1987-88: Patrick Tubbs
2011-2012: Dion McKinley.........Division 3 Ohio Player of the Year
2015-2016 Kyre Allison.......Division 3 Ohio Player of the Year